Answer :
Tom started with 47 cards.
He had 28 left. If his dog ate half then multiply 28 by 2
You get 56
Out of those 56 cards, 9 of them are new
So subtract 9 from 56
You get 47
Tom started with 47 cards
28+28=56
9 are new so 56 - 9 = 47 which is your answer
28+28=56
9 are new so 56 - 9 = 47 which is your answer